'Greater consistency needed' in restrictive practices across Scotland’s secure care
A joint review by the Care Inspectorate and Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland has identified opportunities to improve communication with young people, strengthen health monitoring following restraint and share trauma-informed approaches across secure services.
18/11/26

Secure care services in Scotland and the agencies responsible for placing young people in them should work more closely together to ensure restrictive practices are understood and experienced consistently, according to a new report.
The Care Inspectorate and the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland jointly reviewed children and young people's experiences of restrictive practices, including restraint, between 2025 and 2026. The review involved visits to all four of Scotland's secure services: Good Shepherd Centre Bishopton, Kibble Safe Centre, Rossie Secure Accommodation Services and St Mary's Kenmure.
Inspectors and Commission officers found that many young people felt safe in secure care and valued the trusting relationships they had developed with staff. All four services had clear, child-centred visions and organisational values informed by trauma-informed and rights-based approaches, with an emphasis on understanding the impact of restrictive practices and reducing their use.
Staff were also found to be dedicated and knowledgeable, providing compassionate support that made a positive difference to young people's experiences.
However, the review identified inconsistencies in practice and outcomes across the services, meaning some young people were not benefiting from the most effective approaches to minimising restrictive practices. The report highlights opportunities for services to learn from one another and develop greater consistency across the sector.
One area requiring improvement is how information is shared with young people before and after they enter secure care. Inspectors found that children and young people were not always given a clear understanding of the restrictions they would experience before arriving. More work was also needed to explain the nature of daily life soon after admission, with better communication helping to reduce the anxiety and trauma associated with entering a secure setting.
Young people who had experienced more than one secure care service also described finding different approaches to restrictive practices confusing and unsettling. Given the relatively small and specialist nature of the sector, the report suggests there could be benefits in greater uniformity between services.
The review also identified gaps in the monitoring of young people's physical health following restraint incidents, with insufficiently consistent and evidenced assurance across the services. It recommends that physical wellbeing should be checked after every incident of restraint, with the findings clearly documented in care records.
Although all four services had access to Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS), provision of dedicated psychological services and forensic CAMHS was found to be inequitable across the sector.
The report calls on local authorities and partner agencies responsible for placing young people in secure care to work together to ensure every child receives accessible information about the service they are entering and the restrictions they will experience.
It also recommends that the Scottish Government considers establishing a formal network to share innovative practice and learning between secure care services and policy stakeholders.
Julie Paterson, Chief Executive of the Mental Welfare Commission, said: "We have written to the Scottish Government to advise that research into the impact of the implementation of the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Act 2024 should be considered. The results should inform all stakeholders on the strategic direction and resources required to deliver the reduction of restrictive practices within this new legislative landscape."
Services are also urged to act on improvements identified through the review in relation to recording and quality assurance of restraint and seclusion incidents. Wider scrutiny of restrictive practices should identify recurring themes to inform organisational development and learning, supporting the Promise's ambition for children and young people not to be restrained.
Jackie Irvine, Chief Executive of the Care Inspectorate, said: "The Care Inspectorate will continue to monitor restrictive practice in secure care services as part of their ongoing inspections. The Mental Welfare Commission and the Care Inspectorate will collaborate in 2027 to share progress made in relation to the recommendations detailed above."
Read the full report and Easy Read version: https://www.careinspectorate.scot/resources-data/publications-and-statistics/library/journey-to-trauma-informed-restrictive-practice
£46,579 - £54,143

Featured event
Most popular articles today
Sponsored Content











